Finding the perfect present for the true crime lover in your life can be challenging. There’s no shortage of possible presents, and you want to give one that stands out as truly special and meaningful. So, we found and compiled the best gifts for true crime fans below.
The Serial Killer Cookbook
If you’re searching for gift ideas for someone who loves true crime, then this serial killer cookbook is perfect for them. The author has taken the death row’s last meals of some of America’s most notorious serial killers and given them each their recipe. It includes many recipes for mac and cheese, seared steak, and the infamous “Justice, Equality, and World Peace.”
Infamous Killers Puzzle Book
This puzzle book about notorious murderers would make a fantastic present for any reader interested in true crime. Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, and the Grim Sleeper are just a few of the most infamous serial killers you’ll study in detail. You can find over a hundred serial killer-themed exercises, from coloring pages to memes, in this book to help you better understand these notorious murderers.
Serial Killer Coloring Book
This coloring book is full of notorious murderers and their most gruesome murders. It’s sure to keep them occupied for hours while they color in the pages. This book is so fun and creepy that even Hannibal Lecter would love it.
Crime Scene Chalk Outline Stainless Steel Tumbler
This stainless steel tumbler is ideal for any true crime junkie who wants to drink their coffee in style. With this stainless steel tumbler, they can keep their favorite cold beverage at hand and keep on sleuthing for clues like a true crime investigator. They’ll love drinking their morning coffee from this mug as they watch all their favorite true crime shows.
True Crime Fan Stemless Wine Glass
If you know someone who likes to listen to true crime podcasts, this one-of-a-kind wine glass is the perfect gift for them. This is a clever way to exhibit both their wit and interest in true crime. The glass is 17 ounces in capacity and made of thick, scratch-resistant glass.
I Like Murder Shows True Crime Lover Shirt
This graphic shirt is sure to be a hit with anyone who loves true crime documentaries and wants to show their love in public! This true crime lover shirt is made from high-quality materials and is super comfortable, so it’ll be the perfect shirt for wearing on casual Fridays or running errands around town.
Murder Show Inspired Key Chain
For that one true crime junkie in your life, this murder show key chain is the perfect gift. It’s inspired by one of the most popular true crime podcast and show out there, and it’s a great way to show your favorite true crime fan that you’re thinking about them. This key chain is sure to get a lot of use, whether you’re looking for a unique and funny gift for a friend or family member who loves true crime or just want to treat yourself.
Crime Scene Photographs Scrapbook
The Death Scenes: A Homicide Detective’s Scrapbook is a unique collection of crime scene photographs that were all curated by a real homicide detective. True crime fanatics will love flipping through these pictures and imagining what happened before and after. This crime scene photographs book would make an excellent gift for your favorite true crime aficionado or someone with a morbid sense of humor!
Crime Scene Cookie Cutter
If you can’t get enough of the real stories behind crime scenes, this cookie cutter will make your favorite true crime lover feel like they’re in on the investigation. The crime scene cookie cutter is shaped like a chalk outline of a body, so that true crime fanatics can bake up some treats that look like they’ve been at the scene of an actual crime. This is a fun way to add some intrigue to the holidays and make your favorite true crime lover feel like they’re part of the case.
Knife Cookie Cutter
This is another cookie cutter for your favorite true crime aficionado, and it’s guaranteed to make them laugh. The knife cookie cutter is perfect for making cookies shaped like a knife or for cutting shapes out of dough. It will make them think of the best murder scenes in books or movies. This is the perfect way to show your love and support for their obsession with all things murder, and it will be a conversation starter at every party they attend!
True Crime Documentaries Coffee Mug
Now, that true crime aficionado can take their true crime obsession with them wherever they go. This mug has a fun design, and it’s made of ceramic, so it’ll last a long time. And since it’s dishwasher-safe and microwave-safe, it’ll be easy to clean up.
Serial Killer Blanket
This true crime throw blanket is made with soft and comfortable material, ensuring that it will be a relaxing addition to any room. With its bold red and black design featuring both blood stains and quotes from some of history’s most infamous serial killers, this blanket is sure to be an eye-catching addition to any home decor.
Crime Scene Do Not Cross Lanyard Keychain
This Crime Scene Do Not Cross lanyard is a great accessory for true crime lovers. This lanyard comes with two different crime scene tape designs: one side is traditional yellow with black writing, and one side is black and white with red writing. It also has two metal rings to hold your keys or ID badge, and it’s reversible. You can switch between one side of the tape to match whatever outfit you’re wearing that day!
Crime Scene Evidence Zipper Pouch
The crime scene evidence zipper pouch is made from 95% recycled material. It’s colorful and chunky, so you can tell this is a serious piece of crime scene evidence. It is one of the best gifts for those true crime fanatics in your life. It’s the perfect size for storing all of their essential crime scene evidence items, including pens, pencils, rulers, flashlights, and more!
Encyclopedia of Serial Killers
This encyclopedia is a must-have for any true crime enthusiast. It contains everything you need to know about serial killers: their motives, their methods of operation and disposal of bodies, and even how they were caught. Every page is filled with chilling true crime facts that will make your skin crawl. The book is easy to read and provides information on important criminal historical events.
True Crime Fanatics Trivia Book
This true crime trivia book is perfect for anyone who loves true crime, unsolved mysteries, and creepy details. It’s packed with interesting facts about some of the most famous serial killers in history, including Ted Bundy and Jeffrey Dahmer. Moreover, this trivia book is full of fascinating stories about these cold cases and chilling true crime facts from some of history’s most famous unsolved crimes.
Notorious Killers Playing Cards
These playing cards are perfect for the true crime fanatic in your life. You can play with them, collect them, and learn about some of the most notorious serial killers in American history. They make a perfect Christmas gift for that true crime fan and serial killer enthusiast alike!
Puzzle Book for True Crime Fans
This puzzle book is designed specifically for true crime fans. It features over 1400 words and brain games. The puzzles are all themed around the most famous serial killers in history including Ted Bundy, John Wayne Gacy, Jeff Dahmer, and more, making them even more fun than they would be otherwise.
The Ryan Green Collection
This collection includes four true crime books containing some of the most memorable cases. It’s perfect for any true crime fanatic who wants to dive into a new case. When they open those pages, they’ll find themselves transported into the world of cold case detectives who are determined to solve their cases once and for all or into the minds of killers who just won’t stop killing.
Death at The Dive Bar Mystery Game
If your true crime fan is a little bit of a detective, they’ll love this immersive murder mystery game. The game experience will have them sleuthing around the bar, interrogating suspects, and solving the case, all while enjoying drinks and a great time with friends. They’re going to have so much fun solving this cold case, and you’ll get to feel like a real-life detective while doing it. Plus, the game has easy to follow steps, so you don’t need to know anything about murder mysteries before playing.
True Crime Podcast Comfy T-Shirt
Give the gift of true crime with this comfy t-shirt. This shirt is perfect for true crime lovers obsessed with true crime podcasts, or maybe it’ll be a great gag gift for your favorite podcast host. It’s a funny t shirt that shows their love for the genre, and it will make true crime fans smile when they open it.
My Favorite Murder Mug
Any true crime fanatic would know about the podcast My Favorite Murder. This 11 oz. ceramic coffee novelty mug is great for enjoying coffee while listening to their favorite true crime podcast. It comes gift-wrapped in a clear box with a white bow, so it’s ready for giving!
Stay Sexy Soy Candle
This soy candle is one of the many true crime gifts you can give away to your favorite murderino. It’s a great way to show you love and support their passion. Additionally, it’s a soy candle that smells like murder, with a “Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered” quote on it.
Mixology and Murder Book
This is a great gift for true crime fans. They’ll be entertained all through the year by this mixology and murder book. There are recipes here for every possible event. Mixology and Murder, with its seventy-five recipes for cocktails with a sinister twist, is a must-have for readers interested in true crime.
Jeffrey Dahmer Socks
Serial killer socks are the perfect gift for true crime fans! These Jeffrey Dahmer socks feature the infamous murderer’s face on them, with a blood-splattered background and an ominous message. These Jeffrey Dahmer socks will make any true crime fan smile with glee. Each pair of socks is made of a soft cotton blend, and they’re unisex, so they work great for men or women.
Some Fun Gifts for the True Crime Fan in Your Life
If you have a friend who is a fan of true crime and you have no idea what the perfect Christmas present for them would be, there are a number of options to consider. From vintage detective-themed board games and t-shirts to crosswords and true crime podcast soy candles, we think that there’s something for everyone here.